Opinion | By R.J. Morales | TX3DNews
“This is my seat. I’m going to win it,” Keith Self told NewsNation in October. The host had just played Evan Hunt’s challenge to debate. Self called him “my opponent” without saying his name. He kept the seat. In the Collin County portion of TX-03, the man he left unnamed beat him by 6,668 votes.
By then, Hunt had been asking Self to debate for months. One of those invitations was for a March forum at The Guitar Sanctuary in McKinney. Self declined, and Hunt spent about 90 minutes taking questions from the audience. Other groups invited both candidates, and Self declined those invitations, too. Hunt held monthly virtual town halls and took questions at campaign stops around the district, including in Fairview. Self held no public town halls after January. Some of his gatherings with supporters turned up on his Facebook page after they were over. The two candidates never debated.
Self made Sharia a campaign issue
In October, Self told Context Corner that his campaign’s polling put Sharia a close second among issues in the district. He didn’t release the poll or say what came first. In the same interview, he said he’d told Gov. Greg Abbott that Texas was being lost to Islam.
Collin County had already heard plenty of that argument. Self stood with Abbott at the signing of legislation the governor tied to EPIC City. In August, he urged the McKinney City Council to stop or delay a mosque site plan. Religious assembly was already allowed on the property. The council approved the plan unanimously, and Self said he would sign the petition to recall the mayor and three council members. When radio host Mark Davis asked if he could envision a new mosque he would support, Self answered, “I cannot.”
At his Fairview stop, Hunt said people at their doors brought up schools, health care and household costs. The vote tells us who won Collin County. It can’t tell us how many voters had the mosque in mind. But in the county where Self had made some of his most public arguments about Islam, voters chose Hunt. For a former Collin County judge, that was a rebuke.
Republicans changed who would decide TX-03
Self built most of his winning margin in five counties Republicans added to TX-03 in 2025. They brought in Delta, Franklin, Hopkins, Morris and Titus and moved some Collin County voters out. Apply the same 2024 presidential returns to both maps and Trump’s margin grows from about 20 points to 23. The Legislature made an already Republican district more Republican.
Collin County cast more than four out of every five votes in the race, and Self got less than half of them. In the five counties the Legislature added, he got nearly three out of every four. Those counties cast about one in ten votes districtwide and gave Self an advantage of about 15,100 votes over Hunt. Self also carried the district’s portion of Hunt County, which had already been part of TX-03.
The congressman who called it “my seat” owed most of his winning margin to voters who had been in other congressional districts the last time he ran.
What happens in 2028?
At his September virtual town hall, Hunt said he expected to win or lose by less than five points. Self won by about five and a half. Hunt missed by half a point. Two years earlier, Self had won by 25 points under different district lines. Hunt says he plans to run again. The rest of the Collin County ballot helps explain why.
County Judge Chris Hill held on by 1,342 votes. Keresa Richardson finished seven votes ahead of Brittany Black, and Jeff Leach beat Jordan Wheatley by 128. Angie Carraway unseated Candy Noble. In House District 70, Mihaela Plesa took more than 58 percent against Republican George Flint. Several Republican incumbents kept their seats, and some had to wait for the last ballots to find out.
Self will be 75 in 2028. Will he seek another term after losing his home county? Hunt has said he wants another shot. A rematch would give him a reason to take his town halls to places like Sulphur Springs and Mount Pleasant, where Self built his lead. Whatever Self decides about 2028, he can hold a public town hall in McKinney now. Announce it in advance and let people ask their own questions.
Support Local Journalism
TX3DNews covers the decisions, elections and issues shaping Texas’ 3rd Congressional District.
Your support helps keep independent local journalism available to our community.
Advertise with TX3DNews
Reach readers in Plano, Frisco, McKinney, Allen, Princeton and communities across Texas’ 3rd Congressional District with affordable advertising options for local businesses and organizations.
