By R.J. Morales | TX3DNews
McKINNEY, Texas — Mayor Bill Cox and three City Council members facing recall say they will not resign following Tuesday night’s certification of 6,608 valid petition signatures.
Cox and Councilmembers Justin Beller, Ernest Lynch and Dr. Geré Feltus have until November 22 to decide whether to resign. Those who remain would face a May 1, 2027, recall election, pending City Council action December 1.
“I have no intention of resigning as mayor of McKinney,” Cox said during the November 17 meeting.
Beller confirmed directly to TX3DNews that he will not resign. Feltus previously said she had no intention of stepping down, while Lynch issued a public statement Tuesday expressing the same position.
“I stand by the decisions I’ve made during my first 18 months on the Council,” Lynch wrote. “I respect the right of residents to voice their concerns and take part in the recall process.”
City Secretary Certifies Petition
City Secretary Empress Drane certified 6,608 valid signatures out of 7,422 submitted, exceeding the 5,805 required under McKinney’s City Charter.
Drane said 541 petition pages were submitted September 25. More than three dozen city employees participated in the manual review, which included multiple audits and reconsideration of individual signatures.
“I’m very confident in the work of all of our staff,” Drane told council members. “And ultimately, that falls under my responsibility.”
The recall effort followed the council’s unanimous August approval of the McKinney Islamic Association’s mosque site plan.
The original recall filing cited a loss of public confidence in the four officials. Organizers have since pointed to concerns about city spending, transparency, airport expansion and the U.S. 380 bypass, arguing that city leaders have disregarded residents’ objections.
Residents Defend Council During Public Comments
Before the certification, residents spoke against removing the four officials. No one addressed the council in support of the recall during public comments.
Evan Hunt, who challenged U.S. Rep. Keith Self in November’s congressional election, criticized the recall’s origins and Self’s earlier involvement.
“This recall is rooted in anti-immigrant and anti-Muslim bigotry,” Hunt said, urging residents to revisit Self’s original remarks supporting the effort.
“Complaining is one thing, but demanding that this council subvert the law and act on that prejudice goes against the promise of equal treatment I served 20 years to defend.”
Hunt urged all four officials to seek reelection.
Resident Ken Holliday questioned the justification for recalling council members over a legally compliant site plan.
“Our constitutional protections don’t come with a popularity requirement,” Holliday said.
Not everyone opposing the recall supported the mosque.
Resident Jacinta Sims said she did not want the mosque built but believed the council had followed its legal obligations.
“Do I think our council needs to be recalled? Absolutely not,” Sims said.
Monica Noel, a public school teacher raised in the Methodist Church, told council members she had never spoken at a meeting before but felt compelled to attend.
Noel brought a Quran, read from Chapter 109 and urged residents to approach religious differences with curiosity rather than hostility.
“We should coexist,” she said.
The comments reflected those who spoke Tuesday, not necessarily the views of the broader electorate. The certified petition established that organizers had gathered enough valid signatures to advance the recall.
PAC Raises Concerns Over Published Addresses
Earlier Tuesday, Collin County Citizens for Integrity PAC demanded that McKinney remove petition signers’ home addresses from documents posted online, alleging that recall supporters had already reported threats to police.
“These are families. These are our neighbors,” the PAC said. “The City has jeopardized the safety of its own residents, and it needs to fix this today.”
The PAC also questioned why comparable signer lists were not attached to archived council records from the 2019 Shemwell recall. TX3DNews has not independently verified the reported threats or established whether disclosure practices differed in 2019.
During Tuesday’s meeting, Councilmember Patrick Cloutier questioned whether publishing the petition pages online was legally required or voluntary.
City Manager Paul Grimes said the decision was driven by transparency following criticism of city staff and suggestions that an outside party should review the signatures.
“The direction I had from the very beginning in this process, we were going to be as transparent as possible,” Grimes said.
“There’s nothing that we’re going to hide. Including those who sign the petition.”
Grimes described the petitions as publicly available election documents. He said the city redacted dates of birth and sought guidance from the Texas attorney general’s office about releasing them but had not received a response.
Drane added that making the records available allowed residents to examine how individual signatures were verified. Neither official identified a legal requirement to publish the petition pages online.
What Happens Next
The four officials remain in office while the recall process continues.
City Council is expected to consider election ordinances December 1. If voters recall any officials in May, a separate election in November 2027 would fill the resulting vacancies. If a recall fails, the affected official remains in office.
No recall election has yet been formally ordered.
Support Local Journalism
TX3DNews covers the decisions, elections and issues shaping Texas’ 3rd Congressional District.
Your support helps keep independent local journalism available to our community.
Advertise with TX3DNews
Reach readers in Plano, Frisco, McKinney, Allen, Princeton and communities across Texas’ 3rd Congressional District with affordable advertising options for local businesses and organizations.
