Brittany Black Seeks HD-61 Recount, Wants 45 Overvotes Examined

By R.J. Morales | TX3DNews

COLLIN COUNTY, Texas — Democrat Brittany Black has requested a recount in the Texas House District 61 race, which she trails by seven votes, and wants election officials to take a closer look at 45 ballots recorded as overvotes.

Black filed her petition Wednesday, November 18, following Collin County’s certification of Republican state Rep. Keresa Richardson’s narrow victory. The final results show Richardson with 44,936 votes, Black with 44,929 and Green Party candidate Anissa Chilmeran with 1,704.

“Given that we’re separated by just seven votes, those 45 reported overvotes are absolutely something we want examined to determine whether voter intent can be established and whether any votes were incorrectly rejected,” Black said.

A Closer Look at the Ballots

Collin County’s official results recorded 45 overvotes and 2,751 undervotes in HD-61.

An overvote occurs when more selections are recorded than a race allows. An undervote means no valid selection was counted, either because a voter skipped the contest or because a mark was not recognized.

The overvotes stand out because county election reports recorded none in HD-61 during the 2022 and 2024 general elections.

Black believes the increase may be connected to Collin County’s transition to hand-marked paper ballots, which began with the November 2025 election.

“In previous elections, electronic voting machines generally prevented voters from selecting more than one candidate in the same race, so an overvote wouldn’t have been possible in the same way,” she said. “With paper ballots, however, voters can inadvertently mark more than one selection, or marks can potentially be interpreted incorrectly by the scanner.”

Black said she does not believe all 45 voters necessarily intended to select multiple candidates.

The reported overvotes and undervotes do not establish that any ballots were incorrectly counted.

Collin County Elections Administrator Kaleb Breaux has been asked to explain the increase and how those ballots would be handled during a recount.

What the Campaign Wants

Collin County Democratic Party Chairman Jeremy Sutka said the campaign is particularly interested in overvotes because examining the original markings might reveal a voter’s intended selection.

“The campaign would like to specifically challenge the overvotes especially, as those are most likely to be able to tell a different voter intent than the machine with more review,” Sutka said.

He acknowledged uncertainty about whether the campaign can request that specific examination but said identifying disputed ballots could save time and money.

Black confirmed she requested a full recount. Whether it will be conducted manually or electronically has not been confirmed.

Texas law permits both methods. In a manual recount, officials examine ballot markings and determine voter intent under state rules. Disputes beyond the recount process may require a separate election contest in court.

No separate legal challenge has been announced.

The Cost of Another Count

Sutka said the required $5,600 deposit has been paid and estimated the full recount could cost more than $15,000, excluding potential legal and court expenses.

For Black, financing the recount presents a challenge.

“The decision itself wasn’t particularly difficult. Figuring out how to pay for it is another story,” she said.

Black estimated the expense could equal roughly 20% of her campaign’s spending over the past year.

Asked whether an official cost estimate was available, Black said Thursday, “We can only look at previous examples of recounts to determine an approximation.”

Her campaign is seeking donations to cover the expense.

“We’ve had so many people fighting for us, donating, volunteering, and refusing to give up on this race,” she said. “The least we can do is keep fighting just as hard for them.”

An Election Still on Her Mind

Black described the nearly two weeks between Election Day and the final count as an emotional roller coaster.

“On election night, we started out with a pretty substantial lead, only to watch it shrink as the night went on,” she said.

Richardson finished election night leading by 134 votes. Her advantage narrowed as additional eligible mail and provisional ballots were counted, reaching seven votes November 14. Collin County commissioners canvassed the results November 16.

“To come this close in a district that many considered unwinnable for a Democrat is extraordinary,” Black said. “I’m incredibly proud of what our campaign accomplished, but seven votes is also a difficult number to process.”

She acknowledged how difficult it has been to look back at the campaign.

“You can’t help but think about every conversation, every door knocked, and every person who may have stayed home on Election Day.”

Black contrasted the recount’s potential expense with the $7,200 annual base salary paid to Texas legislators, who also receive per diem compensation.

“At the end of the day, this isn’t about a $7,200-a-year job,” she said. “It’s about making sure the voters of House District 61 have their voices heard and that the final results are accurate. That’s worth fighting for.”

A recount date and final cost have not been confirmed.

Republican state Rep. Keresa Richardson was contacted for comment regarding Black’s recount request but had not responded as of publication.

UPDATE — November 19, 2026 9:00 PM

Collin County Elections Administrator Kaleb Breaux has confirmed that the county’s voting equipment explains why 45 overvotes were recorded in the Texas House District 61 race this year, compared with none in the 2022 and 2024 general elections.

“The ExpressVote ballot marking device, when used, does not allow for a voter to overvote,” Breaux said. “The DS200, when scanning a hand-marked paper ballot, will alert the voter of an overvote situation, but the voter can choose to override the alert and cast the ballot as is.”

The explanation confirms that voters using hand-marked paper ballots can submit their ballots even when the scanner detects more selections than a contest allows. It does not establish whether any of the 45 ballots were counted incorrectly.

Asked whether those ballots would receive individual examination during the recount, Breaux said that would depend on the type of recount requested, adding, “Voter intent has already been determined.”

Breaux also confirmed that, as of his response Thursday, his office had not received official notification of Black’s recount petition from the Texas Secretary of State, although he had seen media reports about the filing.

“Any specifics regarding the recount would be defined in the request, so any response outside of this, at this time, would be sheer speculation,” he said.

The recount’s schedule, counting method and procedures for reviewing the ballots remain unconfirmed.

Support Local Journalism

TX3DNews covers the decisions, elections and issues shaping Texas’ 3rd Congressional District.
Your support helps keep independent local journalism available to our community.

Make a Donation

Advertise with TX3DNews

Reach readers in Plano, Frisco, McKinney, Allen, Princeton and communities across Texas’ 3rd Congressional District with affordable advertising options for local businesses and organizations.

Learn About Advertising

TX3DNews logo

Stay Informed

Get the latest local news delivered to your inbox

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *